Chapter 8 really made me laugh because I have felt "that slightly out-of-hand feeling" a lot through my student teaching, but it wasn't in a positive way. The way Ray talks about it is that there is kind of a stirring about going on in the classroom during writing workshop that many teachers directly relate to being off-task. This is a positive out-of-hand feeling. However, the out-of-hand feeling that I have felt was the sound of a lesson blowing up in my face. The kids were out of control and definitely off-task. Because I know how this terrible example looks in a classroom, I feel that I can more easily see when talk and moving about in the classroom is constructive. Although I can see when talk is constructive, it doesn't mean that I do not struggle with the fact of letting go of the reins, so to speak. I have always had trouble with the fact that in writer's workshop you cannot be in 20 places at one time to tell who is doing what.
Chapter 19 reminded me of where we are at in our own writing. We are all completing pieces and are preparing to publish one of them. Because this is stressful for even college students, I wonder about the impact on elementary kids? It could be that since kids have time each day to write, they have ample time in class to finish things up and don't feel that a deadline equates to stress. However, it also could be that younger students can feel as stressed as older students when they see a deadline approaching. Another thing about publishing- I love the recommendation of sharing the students' published works with pen pals, other students, and even people in the community. I like how this relates to the possible purposes of writing and writing to a certain audience.
I do think that sharing with a wide audience is wonderful experience for kids to have. I think that community people like it, too. A well written letter on a community issue is hard for a politician to ignore, for example.
ReplyDeleteAs I was planning for tomorrow's class, I felt myself wishing we met every day. I have all these ideas for revision, but I can't cram too much in at once or nothing will stick...I know that you all will see much more doing this daily, and can help students directly as they get close to publishing.